The Most Powerful People in Wine

Last month's (I think -- I'm way behind on my reading)
Decanter magazine had an interesting feature on the "most powerful people in the wine world" and the list they put together is worth sharing and commenting on (I encourage you to take a look at the issue as they have profiles of most of the people on their list).

So what does power mean? To Decanter, powerful means having a direct influence on the style of wine being drunk around the world today. Each of their selections (50 in total) were chosen for the level and reach of that impact.

Additionally each of these individuals was evaluated on their reach (how global their influence was), their role as a pioneer, their financial clout, their connection with "wines great and good," or their hands-on involvement in winemaking.

Richard Sands, CEO and Chairman, Constellation Brands, US
Robert Parker, Critic, US
Mel Dick, SVP Southern Wine and Spirits, US
Michel Rolland, Consultant Winemaker, France
Jacques Chirac, President of France
Ernest Gallo, Chairman E&J Gallo, US
Patrick Ricard, Chairman & CEO Pernod Ricard, France
Nancy Griese, VP Foods & Sundries, Costco, US
Hugh Johnson, Writer and Consultant, UK
Travis Engen, CEO, Alcan, Canada
Piero Antinori, Director Marchese Antinori, Italy
Mark Murphy, Wine Category Director, Tesco, UK
Jancis Robinson, Critic, Wine Writer, UK
Trevor O'Hoy, CEO, Foster's, Australia
Marvin Shanken, Publisher, US
Rene Renou, President INAO (Institut National des Apellations d'Origine), France
Steven Spurrier, Writer and Consultant, UK
Nobutada Saji, CEO, Suntory, Japan
Miguel Torres, President, Torres, Spain
Jean-Marie Chadronnier, President and CEO, CVBG Dourthe Kressmeann, France

So. First of all, I hate lists like this. They're reductive, simple, and trite, and don't acknowledge the complexity of the world we live in at all. Having said that, however, they always make for good discussion, or at least some musings, regardless of whether you agree with the rankings, or the concept of creating such lists at all (I don't).

What's interesting about this list? Well, worth noting is that 40% of the people in the top 20, including the number one on the list are part of huge corporate entities -- either retailers, distributors, or wine & spirits conglomerates. Whether or not some people refuse to admit it, and regardless of the passion involved, wine is a business for nearly everyone involved. It's hard to reconcile that reality sometimes with the poetry of the process and the magic of the results, but like it or not, it's true.

It was interesting to me to see the CEO of Alcan (manufacturer of the Stelvin screwcap wine closure) so high on the list. This seems more like a predictive nomination than a rating of current power.

No surprise to see Parker at number two on the list, but I wonder why he's not number one? Constellation is the largest wine company in the world, accounting for 22% of the sales of wine in the US and 17% in the UK, but I wonder if despite their size they really have the ability to make a market like Parker seems to be able to.

Having Jacques Chirac on the list is like having Arnold Schwarzenegger on the list because he happens (for the moment) to be the governor of the state that Napa happens to be in. It's silly.

I only recently learned that Costco was the largest retailer of wine in the US. What I didn't know is that their wine sales have increased by 500% in the last seven years.

It was interesting to see the CEO of Suntory on the list, but they apparently import about 4 billion dollars worth of wine each year to Japan, from 13 different countries.

Finally there was one person/company in the top 20 that I had never heard of. CVBG Dourthe Kressmeann is apparently "one of Bordeaux's most influential - and dynamic - negociants, exporting more wines by value than any other firm." The President, Chadronnier, is also the head of VinExpo.

What do you think?

Posted by: Alder on August 14, 2005 10:09 PM: Tweet; Share this post elsewhere: Digg it! - Add to del.icio.us - Add to Stumbleupon - Add to Reddit; Filed under: Ramblings and Rants

Previous Entry - Main - Next Entry

Comments (7)

Derrick Schneider wrote:

08.14.05 at 10:21 PM

I was surprised by the #2 slot for Robert Parker as well, until I realized that the vast majority of my casual wine-drinking friends don't know who Robert Parker is. But they're probably drinking wines from the Constellation firmament.

Lenn wrote:

08.15.05 at 7:32 AM

My question is this:

Where is Alder Yarrow on this list? ;)

HugeJ wrote:

08.15.05 at 9:59 AM

I think they've confused their terms a bit, particularly with regard to Mel Dick and Richard Sands. These are people who control distribution of wine (to a huge degree, I might add), but don't directly influence style or trends.

I don't disagree with their ranking (though I might put Mel Dick at #1), but I think the criteria wasn't explained correctly. Probably they should have done one list for power(in the market) and one list for authority(influence of style). Two very different things....

/huge

Nancy wrote:

08.19.05 at 1:43 AM

Is the full Decanter article available online or only in print? I'm keen to see the full list. I'd appreciate a direct link if anybody has spied the article online.

Best.

Nancy

Alder wrote:

08.19.05 at 8:51 AM

Nancy,

As far as I know the full article is only available in the magazine. It's the july issue.

Francesco wrote:

11.28.05 at 10:34 PM

I think one the most influential Italian wine makers is definitely Piero Antinori. He is a Wine making God in my book! Probably one of the most honest Italian wineries out there today.

Alexie wrote:

01.22.12 at 5:34 AM

I agree with Jacques Chirac being on the list. He is a well-known teetotaler and many people in France - including various members of various French embassies - link his anti-alcohol stance with the declining fortunes of wine in France.