Text Size:-+
05.23.2010

1980 Soldera Case Basse Brunello Riserva, Montalcino, Italy

soldera_bottle.jpgWhen I was a kid, I read a lot of science fiction. On long plane flights I still occasionally pick up a book to read, and I still get a thrill from letting my imagination explore the fantastic possibilities of the future.

Perhaps it's a bit of a stretch as an analogy, but I get that same sort of thrill from exploring the world of wine. Every new wine offers an opportunity to discover and learn something new -- to recalibrate my own sense of possibility.

On occasion, in my curiosity-driven stumbling through the world of wine, I come across a wine that completely redefines my understanding of a category. These wines make my head explode. They take my understanding of a particular kind of wine and they nonchalantly obliterate it, leaving me with a feeling of having just woken up from a dream.

This is one of those wines.

To call such experiences epiphanies may be a little overly dramatic, but it is both alarming and euphoric to have what you think is the truth of your understanding completely redefined in an instant.

I thought I knew what Brunello was, and what it was capable of. I've traveled in Tuscany, visiting many producers to sample their wines. I've eaten at fancy restaurants in Tuscany, buying older bottles out of their cellars to drink. I regularly attend trade tastings put on by the Brunello Consortium that showcase the latest vintage to members of the media and trade; and I attend the Gambero Rosso tasting every year, which highlights some of the best wines in Italy, bar none.

All the above doesn't make me an expert in Brunello. Far from it. But I thought I had "a handle on it." You know? A sense of what it tastes like in the barrel, after bottling, and with some age on it -- even ten, twenty, or thirty years. I've considered myself pretty lucky for that experience, not only because of the education it has given my palate, but because it has allowed me to fall in love with the wine. I adore Brunello di Montalcino.

But I didn't know just how much I loved it until I met the handiwork of Gianfranco Soldera.

Here's how Sergio Esposito, owner of the Italian Wine Merchant, and author of a memoir called Passion on the Vine describes Soldera in his book: "Gianfranco Soldera seemed like your average retiree -- a little grumpy and very hunched. He was short, with a substantial nose and belly, tufts of white hair around his ears, a mustache, and a pair of enormously messy gray eyebrows that gave him a consistently sympathetic expression." Not exactly what you'd expect for someone that clearly qualifies as one of the visionary winemakers of the world.

Most of the way through a successful career as a commercial insurance salesman in Milan, Gianfranco Soldera announced to his business partners that he would be leaving the company just as soon as he found the right plot of land. He and his wife Graziella began searching for a small estate where the two could begin a new phase of their lives, he as a winegrower, she (a botanist by training) as a curator of roses. Apparently their search took them throughout Italy, to Piemonte, the Veneto, and finally to Tuscany, where thanks to a tip from Soldera's uncle they discovered a plot of land with a tiny, disintegrating farmhouse south of the hill town of Montalcino in 1971 that felt just right.

It's hard to describe exactly what the Solderas have accomplished in the past forty years, as most conventional descriptions fall somewhat short. They have not merely established a farm, or built a winery, or landscaped an estate. They seem to have created something that demands a new word, a word that can somehow convey a cross between a botanical garden, an ecosystem, and a living museum, not to mention what is widely regarded as one of the greatest wine estates on the planet.

To my knowledge Soldera doesn't consider himself to be a practitioner of biodynamics, but he has certainly taken to heart one of the key principles -- the creation of a balanced, complete ecosystem on his property. With a keen attention to pollinators, pests, grazers, predators, and the merely decorative, Soldera and his wife (who has planted more than 1500 varieties of roses on the property) have cultivated a chunk of Tuscan countryside into something close to edenic.

And that doesn't even include the grapevines.

Though there are a lot fewer grapevines than most other plants on Soldera's Case Basse estate. The land contains two tiny plots of vineyard: the approximately 4.5-acre Case Basse vineyard, and the approximately 13-acre Intistieti vineyard. Every vine is one of several various clones that Soldera ferreted out of nooks and crannies throughout Tuscany and propagated himself.

From these small plots, worked painstakingly by hand and completely organically (though not certified as such), Soldera produces about 1,250 cases of wine each year. That is, if he feels the wines are good enough.

The grapes are picked painstakingly in multiple passes through the vineyard, and fully destemmed but not crushed before they are dumped into big open-top oak fermentation vats. Without a shred of temperature control the wines ferment using ambient yeasts, with a long maceration, before ending up in the traditional old Slavonian oak barrels where they stay for at least four years and sometimes six. After the wines are bottled, they are aged for another couple of years before release. No fining or filtration is ever performed, and only a minimum of sulfur dioxide is used at bottling.

Just how this ambitious insurance executive turned himself into one of the greatest makers of Brunello di Montalcino in the world is a bit of a mystery. The help of one of the world's foremost experts on Sangiovese, Giulio Gambelli, certainly didn't hurt, but at the end of the day, Soldera has always made the wine. He set out to make, in his words, "the best wine in the world" and while I don't think there can or should ever be a single best wine in the world, I wouldn't hesitate to suggest that Soldera's belong amongst the very top.

This particular bottle, opened by a stunningly generous friend in New York, has a slightly confusing label. While it bears the name of his Case Basse estate, the grapes for this wine actually came from the Intistieti vineyard instead of the eponymous Case Basse vineyard. This was the case for many years with the regular Brunello, until Soldera switched to feature the Case Basse fruit, and bottle Intistieti under its own label. Adding to the confusion, for several more years after this switch, the Riserva bottling continued to be made with Intistieti fruit.

Tasting Notes:
Medium ruby in color, with a rim of orange seeping towards the red heart of the glass, this wine has an absolutely otherworldly nose of toffee, candied orange peel, and exotic wood aromas. These aromas shift and shimmer and transform into other passing smells the longer you keep your nose in the glass. When I first put the wine into my mouth it stopped me dead in my tracks. Had I not had the distinct pleasure of smelling it first, I can only imagine what the shock of utter deliciousness might have done to me. As it is, the wine knocked me back in my chair, and resulted in several expletives making their way into my tasting notes, the most legible of which is "holy fuck." Sandwiched in between four letter words were ethereal flavors of sandalwood oil, redcurrant skin, raspberry, toffee, and aromatic dried flowers borne on a texture that was pure, sexy, liquid silk. This bottle possessed one of the greatest finishes I have ever experienced on a wine, with lingering flavors of sweet coffee with milk, butterscotch, and honey that I could still taste for minutes after a sip. Like so many truly great wines, this wine was purely effortless in its complexion. Singularly balanced, seamless, and above all, alive, the wine sang with the resonant clarity of a tuning fork, and is without a doubt one of the best things I have ever had the pleasure of putting in my mouth. Not to mention being the single best Brunello di Montalcino I have ever had.

Food Pairing:
While it's tempting in a fit of melodrama to suggest that a wine this phenomenal only be enjoyed with the lights out and holding the hand of the person you care about most in the world, it loses none of its joy when paired with food. At this state of age, the wine has an incredible versatility that will allow it to counterpoint nearly anything (even artichokes, Soldera likes to point out). I would recommend drinking it with something that has a salty, savory, and aromatic edge to it so that the aromatic sweetness of the wine can really shine. Rosemary-rubbed, grilled lamb chops, anyone?

Overall Score: around 10

How Much?: I have no idea what this wine sold for on release, but it now sells at auction and on the secondary market for somewhere around $500.

You can find small quantities of many Soldera vintages available for purchase on the Internet.

Comments (10)

Gence wrote:
05.24.10 at 6:34 AM

I can only relate, you will never be the same again because of this bottle, and that's a good thing.

Jen Frank wrote:
05.24.10 at 4:05 PM

Alder, I can totally relate. I had a life altering tasting moment the first time I experienced Soldera Brunello. Will never forget it. Now if I can just have some more!

christopher.n.robinson@gmail.com wrote:
05.24.10 at 5:43 PM

Having dinner with Soldera's daughter this Friday. She is in town for Vinexpo. Let's see what all the fuss is about - wine and daughter!!

BaroloDude wrote:
05.25.10 at 8:19 AM

can i have your generous friend's phone number? I love BdM, but have never been that knocked back by one yet. Will start saving my money.
Great one today Alder.

Le Bon Vin wrote:
05.27.10 at 9:21 AM

Have you ever tried Brunello by Terranova? If you like the Soldera, you would probably like this wine. Full-bodied with blackberry and chocolate flavors, it's very smooth and silky. Altogether an excellent red wine.

Brian wrote:
05.30.10 at 7:13 PM

I was poured a glass of Soldera as part of a tasting flight at the castle in Montalcino. The woman pouring was an American ex-pat living there who was brought along one day as a translator for an interview of Gianfranco. She related having to translate him stating that he was the only one making wine in Montalcino, that everyone else made soft-drinks. They are indeed mindblowing wines in a sea of mediocrity.

christopher.n.robinson@gmail.com wrote:
05.31.10 at 2:48 AM

Alder, I met the daughter Monica and she was a real pleasure. She is an economist by training, has been a senior marketing manager for a major multi-national and has obviously been exposed to English through that. She is very proud of her father and her mother's achievements (mum's food and 1000 plus varietal rose garden!!) and has "retired" from marketing to help with Soldera, leaving behind the pleasures of Milan for Montalcino. Her views and comments about the total commitment of her father to allowing nature to completely run things was amazing. She said the property is so "natural" that bats now help cleaning up the pests, whereas in most vineyards they have disappeared. She talks about her father's views in terms of symbiosis and believes that eventually nature settles into a pattern that is ultimately ideal. We tasted a 2002, 2003 Soldera Riserva and a new wine called Pegasus which is released early because dad said it "it was ready" (after 4 years, not the usual 6 years). I can't add anything more as comments about these wines. They are simply sublime with the layers of aromas and flavours from them. I did however comment that they seemed very Burgundian in structure and appeal and she agreed, saying her father also felt this. At 200-250 USD a bottle it is a brave (and wealthy) buyer, but .. well, I am looking for them right now. Acker had some at auction in Hong Kong and all sold. BTW Monica asked me to send her this blog, which I shall do, so additional blogs welcomed I guess. And another BTW, that Bordeaux-shaped bottle was designed by her father precisely to match the wine. Apparently it drove the bottle manufacturers crazy.

Le Bon Vin wrote:
06.02.10 at 8:58 AM

My mistake, Terranova (a Philadelphia importer) imports the Brunello, but I think Tinazzi makes it...

11.30.11 at 3:17 PM

All the comments ring true for me as well. The company I spent the last ten yeasr with until two months ago - Domaine Select Wine Estates - is the sole US Importer for Soldera - Case Basse. Spending time with Gianfranco in the gardens, the cellar and over amazing dinners count as some of my most special memories in the world of wine. Monica Soldera is doing a fantastic job in translating her father's words and mission. Last summer Monica's brother Mauro spent the summer on sabbatical from his day job as an attorney to travel the US and work with the Domaine Select team and fortunate wine buyers and some luck consumers. Four days a week for about 9 weeks we had both 2002 and 2003 Brunello Riserva open to taste and occasionally we opened the amazing 2005 Pegasos. Wow! What a summer! This is a special family in a special place creating magical wines.

m.nurzia@virgilio.it wrote:
02.22.13 at 1:42 AM

Ho letto i vostri interessanti commenti. Sono in possesso di varie bottiglie di annata (perfettamente conservate) e in particolare di una bottiglia di Soldara 1980. Vorrei chiedere quanto potrei realizzare e dove vendere on line.
cordialità.

Comment on this entry

(will not be published)
(optional -- Google will not follow)
Yes
 

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Pre-Order My Book!

small_final_covershot_dropshadow.jpg A wine book like no other. Photographs, essays, and wine recommendations. Learn more.

Follow Me On:

Twitter Facebook Pinterest Instagram Delectable Flipboard

Most Recent Entries

Vinography Images: Rising Light Book Review: The Essential Scratch and Sniff Guide to Becoming a Wine Expert The Beauty of 2011 Burgundy: Highlights from La Paulee de San Francisco Seven Percent Solution Tasting: May 8, San Francisco Vinography Images: Autumn Cellar Vinography Images: Vines and Sky Are You a Red, Pink or a Purple Wine Stater? 2014 TAPAS Iberian Varieties Tasting: April 27, San Francisco Taste Washington Day One in Brief Vinography Images: Trailing Vine

Favorite Posts From the Archives

Masuizumi Junmai Daiginjo, Toyama Prefecture Wine.Com Gives Retailers (and Consumers) the Finger 1961 Hospices de Beaune Emile Chandesais, Burgundy Wine Over Time The Better Half of My Palate 1999 Királyudvar "Lapis" Tokaji Furmint, Hungary What's Allowed in Your Wine and Winemaking Why Community Tasting Notes Sites Will Fail Appreciating Wine in Context The Soul vs. The Market 1989 Fiorano Botte 48 Semillion,Italy

Archives by Month

 

Required Reading for Wine Lovers

The Oxford Companion to Wine by Jancis Robinson The Taste of Wine by Emile Peynaud Adventures on the Wine Route by Kermit Lynch Love By the Glass by Dorothy Gaiter & John Brecher Noble Rot by William Echikson The Science of Wine by Jamie Goode The Judgement of Paris by George Taber The Wine Bible by Karen MacNeil The Botanist and the Vintner by Christy Campbell The Emperor of Wine by Elin McCoy The World Atlas of Wine by Hugh Johnson The World's Greatest Wine Estates by Robert M. Parker, Jr.