Text Size:-+

Highlights From the 2010 Symposium for Professional Wine Writers

I spent most of the week playing hooky from my day job and pretending that the only thing that mattered to me was writing about wine. It was a lot of fun. Every one of the five years that I've attended the Symposium for Professional Wine Writers has been uniquely interesting, largely due to the group of attendees that joins us every time.

In past years I've been able to blog a bit more in the course of the event, but this year I found myself using spare time to catch up on other things, so here are some of the highlights from this year's event.

What Wine Writers Need to Know about Winemaking
We were joined by Jeff Morgan, winemaker for, among other things, the kosher red wine Covenant. Jeff also has "done time" as a wine writer for the Wine Spectator and other outlets, so he seemed quite appropriate as a speaker. Unfortunately given only 45 minutes to cover a lot of ground, Jeff took us through the mechanics and chemistry of winemaking until several somewhat controversial statements resulted in a flurry of questions and debate that ate up the rest of his time.

The first thing Jeff maintained was that approximately 80% of California winemakers "water back" a practice that involves adding water to the juice prior to fermentation as a means of lowering the alcohol of the final wine. This practice was so common, he maintained, that journalists needn't even bother to ask winemakers whether they did it or not.

Jeff also suggested that acidulation (the addition of tartaric acid) was nearly as common in all but a few of the coolest growing regions of California. He also went on to make points about the use of sulfur dioxide in winemaking or at least in bottling (important, he said for keeping wines from being "naturally awful"), and the current dance of yields, hang-time, and brix levels for the ripening of fruit.

Several members of the crowd brought up the question of alcohol levels and whether watering back was really just treating the symptom of a larger malaise and that's where the debate got lively. Unfortunately we ran out of time before clear arguments could be made on either side.

The Evolution of the Tasting Note
Eric Asimov, chief wine critic for the New York Times, and Karen MacNeil, author of The Wine Bible, presided over another interesting session focused on both the theory and practice of writing tasting notes. Eric introduced the session as a continuation of his talk last year which he entitled The Tyranny of the Tasting Note.

Here's a summary transcript of his opening remarks.

"My point last year was that tasting notes were not merely comical, they are pernicious. They are the dominant mode of talking about wine in our culture. People read and hear tasting notes as they get into wine and think that they are the way they should talk about wine. But by focusing on enumerating every last flavor and aroma, tasting notes reduce wine to something certain, definable, and clinical. And wine is not so easily defined.

The more we know about wine, the more we find out it is highly subjective, contextual, and mysterious. Tasting notes tend to rip out mystery that is at the heart of a wine and replaces it with unambiguous solidity.

The tasting note way of talking or thinking about wine produces the kind of anxiety that pervades the culture of wine in America. People who drink wine casually and read tasting notes that include esoteric and definite flavors and aromas they don't themselves experience think that there is something wrong with them. They chalk it up to their lack of experience, but not without a great deal of anxiety that ultimately prevents them from appreciating wine as it is meant to be appreciated.

Those few who manage to get past this anxiety and move on to real excitement about wine assume that tasting notes are the way to talk about wine, because that's the dominant paradigm.

We absolutely need to describe wine to our readers. But I want to contrast the absolute definite specificity that you see in typical kinds of tasting notes, with the kind of note that I think is much more effective. Yesterday Frances [author Frances Mayes, the keynote speaker for the conference] called a wine "fruit basket fresh" yesterday. That communicates so much. You don't have to know the specific flavor involved, yet you have a sense of the wine.

My thought in talking about wine and describing wines, is not to come up with a litany of flavors and aromas. But come up with characteristics that you say directly or to which you make allusions. Convey style, convey intent and convey achievement. People need to know what they're going to get themselves into when they open a bottle, they don't need an effort to pin down every last flavor in the wine. List characteristics rather than ingredients.

Before we start tasting wine, I want to distinguish between public tasting notes and private tasting notes. I'm talking about the notes we publish. As writers or wine lovers we also write notes to ourselves to remind us what we're tasting, and to remember wines later on. For the purpose of a mnemonic device it doesn't matter what you're writing -- whatever works for you is fine. But the private modes of communication that help you relive or remember the wine don't work for public consumption. This is an effort to think again about how we describe wine and what it is we are going to communicate to readers."

Karen MacNeil reminded us of the history of wine writing, and then treated us to a reading of one of the most amusingly convoluted and erudite tasting notes I've ever heard in my life, which was so complex I was not able to follow it enough to write it down.

The rest of the session was spent actually tasting wine blind and writing tasting notes which were shared and discussed. Some people took Eric's suggestion of metaphor quite literally. The session got amusing as silk thongs and velvet condoms made appearances as descriptors. I'm not sure, however, if that is what Eric was getting at.

The Recession and What it Means for Wine
One of the most interesting presentations at the conference was given by Vic Motto, CEO of Global Wine Partners. He offered an extremely articulate argument for the notion that the sky is not, in fact, falling.

I'm sure I can't do full justice to the many detailed points of his argument, but I can try to boil it down. He essentially wanted to convey that while these are certainly tough times at the moment, the wine industry in the United States is poised for significant growth in the future thanks to the inexorable and unchangeable nature of demographics. The single greatest guarantee of the successful future of the industry is the Millennial generation, a generation characterized by its size (70 million of them, 50% of which are just entering their 20s) and the cultural desire to drink differently than the parent generation (which means wine, not beer and spirits, at a rate twice any generation in modern history).

Combine this unavoidable train full of wine drinkers hurtling down the tracks with the increasing availability of channels to purchase wine and the ever widening selection of what is available as well as the increasing interest in lifestyle in general (with wine a big part of defining one's lifestyle) and you've got a recipe for a big wine boom.

And that is just in the united states. According to Motto, 1.2 billion people have been added to the global middle class in the last 20 years, and in another 20 years, a full 50% of the globe will be considered middle class in terms of their consumption habits and wealth levels. If the evidence from China is any indication, this middle class will have a very strong interest in wine.

In short, there's light at the end of the tunnel for sure, we're just not sure how long the tunnel is.

Ethics and Income Streams for Wine Writers
Steve Heimoff of the Wine Enthusiast led a very interesting panel discussion that devolved into a larger group discussion on ethics for wine writers. The conversation was wide-ranging, and covered samples, transparency, relationships to PR and industry, junkets/press trips, advertising, and reputation, among other things.

His panelists were Michael Bauer, executive Food and Wine editor for the San Francisco, Chronicle; Heather John, Sr. Editor at Bon Appetit Magazine and blogger at The Foodinista; and Thomas Ulrich, a contributing writer for Wines & Vines Magazine and professor of Journalism at San Jose State University.

Ethics seem to be an endless source of lively conversations among wine writers, for reasons I can't entirely fathom, and this panel did not prove otherwise. The most interesting aspects of the discussion for me came from Heather John, who, after suggesting she might need to go into the Witness Protection Program, served up the following bomb:

Wine writers have some of the worst reputations for bad ethics in the business.

She went on to explain that she knows a lot of people in the PR industry, and they constantly complain (or salaciously dish) about wine writers and their bad behavior. The kinds of things involved included requesting multiple bottles of samples; asking for free meals or free wine in restaurants; attending a free dinner and ordering the most expensive wine on the list; asking for the keys to winery guest houses or for free lodging; hitting on publicists; bad mouthing wineries to publicists; and in one particular case, threatening to write negative stories about a PR person's clients unless they footed the bill for a trip the writer wanted to go on.

When asked whether the main offenders were print journalists or bloggers, she said print journalists without hesitation (I cheered). She went on to say, however, that in her experience and in the experience of her friends in PR, the two areas that bloggers seem to abuse are samples and what she called "seat warming." -- the practice of attending every press luncheon, dinner, or other free food function possible.

Michael Bauer offered an interesting point relative to the respective ethics of traditional and new media writers as the session closed. He suggested that print journalists borrow the reputation of their masthead, while bloggers have to earn their reputations as they go. I thought this was quite elegantly phrased as well as profoundly accurate.

Sadly the session ran out of time before we could have a discussion of the recent FTC rulings on the ethics of free samples, which I would have liked to hear the group discuss. Many of the "traditional" media wine writers I talked with at the conference were really appalled at the double standard in the ruling.

* * *

And there you have it. You can find additional coverage of the Symposium, including some of the sessions I did not attend at Steve Heimoff's blog, OneWineDude.Com, AWineStory.Com, and at On The Wine Trail in Italy.

Comments (29)

CharlieOlken wrote:
02.21.10 at 1:16 AM

Alder has left out the very important job he had in moderating a panel of writers who discussed one of the compelling issues for so many bloggists in the crowd. That is the question of how one can ever make any money in exchange for spending enormous amounts of time writing about wine.

Yes, many, even most of the 1500 estimated wine blogs, are not really about moneymaking. But, I can say this even if Alder will not, the time, energy and money devoted to doing very good research and writing is significant.

And, at some point, some of the people who are now not making much money, if at all, are going to need to get paid for what they do.

Alder wrote an April Fools article about beginning to charge for his blog, and he received a great deal of advice that told him "no dice", even though his comments were clearly meant to amuse us all.

Still, the topic is a lively one for many blog writers who would like very much to make a living by writing about wine. And it will not go away.

And now that I have introduced Alder's participation in this discussion, perhaps he will be less shy about blowing his own horn a bit.

wick wrote:
02.21.10 at 8:53 PM

Alder, you say, “Ethics seem to be an endless source of lively conversations among wine writers, for reasons I can't entirely fathom..”

Dr Vino highlighted the questionable ethics of the gang at Wine Advocate as well as the editorial practices of Anthony Diaz Blue…

Just this morning on Steve Hiemoff’s blog, a vintner suggests,

If you guys want to make serious money from online wine blogging, create a system that drives (new) end-users to specific winery websites and I am positive, as long as the unique sessions can be tracked, wineries will pay out.

If I knew a case was purchased online (sight un tasted) from a guy in TX who read a blog review and became excited about the wines… enough to purchase, yeah the person who posted who get a “driver’s fee”.

To which Steve rightly points out “it raises questions of conflict of interest.”

And you are not sure why it’s such an issue?

Hope that helps.

02.22.10 at 5:33 AM

The way I view ethics questions: if you have to ask, then you already know the answer.

Heather describes an awful lot of people I've met in my wine career. And usually, the ethics skaters are the ones that will do other nasty things--to colleagues.

Having said that, I don't think this kind of problem or behavior is confined to wine writers. It so happens to be human nature to seek the easy path--or would that be the low road? ;)

1WineDude wrote:
02.22.10 at 5:44 AM

You're just jealous that you didn't come up with the thong thread before I did. :-)

It was fun to hear you mutter "uh-ohhh" when they handed me the mic at the tasting notes exercise (am I *that* transparent?).

Arthur wrote:
02.22.10 at 11:58 AM

The problem with the suggestion of a "system that drives (new) end-users to specific winery websites" has to do with compensation. In California, bloggers cannot post ads on their sites which involve commission-type compensation. This puts all California-based bloggers out of the running.

Tish wrote:
02.22.10 at 12:52 PM

Nice wrap-up Alder. The symposium was extra-successful this year in large part thanks to your ability to spread the info across the twitterverse; the #wws2010 was quite engaging, and proof that 140 characters are in no way a limitation, but rather a gateway to a diverse, real-time Conversation.

Stepping back for a minute, I find it fascinating to theink of mow much more influence this symposium (and other tweetable events) can and will have moving forward, thanks to the ever-evoling beast we now call Social Media.

And the mere fact that this discussion has already blossomed online is prrof positive that online content -- including bu not limited to blogging -- has already surpassed traditional print media in relevance to thos who actually practice of wine writing.

02.22.10 at 7:56 PM

Alder, it's sad to see you so misrepresent what really went on in your and my panels at the Symposium. I'll blog on this soon.

Alder Yarrow wrote:
02.22.10 at 8:03 PM

Steve: huh? I didn't say anything about my panel (as I'm busy formatting the video I made of it for sharing online) and I'm baffled as to how you think I might have misrepresented your panel....

perloca.com wrote:
08.22.14 at 3:32 PM

This is a topic that's near to my heart...

Cheers! Exactly where are your contact details

08.23.14 at 2:04 AM

you'r? truly a just r?ght webmaster. The web site
loading pace is incredible. It kind of feels that
you a?e d?ing anyy distinctive trick. Furthermore, The contents are masterpiece.
?ou've done a excellent activity on this

08.23.14 at 2:55 AM

Its such as you read my thoughts! You seem to grasp a lot
approximately this, such as you wrote the book
in it or something. I think that you can do with some percent to power the message home a little bit, but instead of that, that is great
blog. A fantastic read. I will certainly be back.

08.23.14 at 6:50 AM

I was recommended this web site by way of my cousin. I am not sure whether this
publish is written through him as no one else recognise
such certain about my trouble. You're wonderful! Thank you!

08.23.14 at 7:39 AM

I am sure this article has touched all the internet visitors, its really really fastidious article on building up new website.

08.23.14 at 8:00 AM

This website was... how do I say it? Relevant!! Finally I've found something which helped me.

Many thanks!

08.23.14 at 12:13 PM

?h?s is a topic that ?s near t? my heart... Many t?anks!

Exa?tly w?ere ar? your contact details though?

08.23.14 at 3:17 PM

This website was... how do you say it? Relevant!!
Finally I have found something that helped me.
Appreciate it!

ilustratii wrote:
08.23.14 at 3:45 PM

Simply desire to say your article is as astonishing.
The clearness in your post is simply cool and i can assume
you are an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission let me to grab your feed to keep up
to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please carry on the enjoyable work.

08.23.14 at 8:12 PM

Your way of telling everything in this paragraph is actually nice,
all can simply know it, Thanks a lot.

08.24.14 at 4:01 PM

We're a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community.
Your website provided us with valuable info to work on. You have done an impressive job and our whole
community will be grateful to you.

08.24.14 at 6:38 PM

If you capitol roofing find any such places, fill them
up with metal caulk.

08.24.14 at 8:42 PM

Hi, after reading this awesome piece of writing i am as well happy to share my experience here with

test wrote:
08.24.14 at 11:25 PM

Appreciating the persistence you put into your blog and detailed information you offer.
It's nice to come across a blog every once in a while that isn't the same unwanted rehashed information. Wonderful read!
I've bookmarked your site and I'm adding your RSS feeds to my Google account.

08.24.14 at 11:42 PM

Greetings! This iss my first comment here so I just wanted to give
a quick shoutt out and tell you I truly enjoy reading your articles.
Can you suggest any other blogs/websites/forums that deal with the same topics?
Appreciate it!

08.25.14 at 10:05 AM

Here are some of the people who need them. They capitol roofing had to
find a reliable, trustworthy roofing contractor. But, nowadays, corrugated
roofing sheets, translucent corrugated roofing sheets, opaque corrugated
& plain roofing sheets, unlike shingles or roofing solutions before they are installed correctly.
Step 1; is to stop the bleeding. Usually they could include: plywood, OSB oriented strand board sheathing, wood tongue and
groove, corrugated metal page roofing is a green and
environmental friendly option. The cost of a metal roof
to last?

??????????? wrote:
08.26.14 at 12:57 AM

I'm curious to find out what blog system you are working with?
I'm experiencing some minor security issues with my latest website and
I'd like to find something more safe. Do you have any recommendations?

08.26.14 at 3:04 AM

Wonderful blog! I found it while surfing around on Yahoo News.
Do you have any tips on how to get listed in Yahoo
News? I've been trying for a while but I never seem
to get there! Many thanks

08.26.14 at 2:54 PM

New Balance 999 Balance 996 Femme dhArk Pieno zeppo di immagini agghiaccianti: una donna in un sari rosso
penetrante il silenzio con le sue urla, un uomo dagli occhi selvaggio che emerge dal buio per salutare un bambino,
il sacrificio crudele di un pollo Another Planet è un film breve inquietante sui
misteri della vita del villaggio in India .
Il film è la storia di una giovane ragazza in un villaggio la cui madre sta morendo, che la porta a
cercare l'aiuto di un uomo santo demoniaca.
Balance 420 Homme Balance 999 Homme uIotw Il nome è talvolta Baum libro (in alcune versioni di Volkov
Volkov spiega le origini del libro, l'appendice)
è accreditato. Alcuni elementi di Baum
nomi dei personaggi nuovi rimossi, modificati e aggiunti alcuni elementi nuovi.
Balance 996 Femme Balance 574 Homme hxTyz Poi iniziò la vera e
propria esperienza di apertura degli occhi. Abbiamo tutti un regalo http://lot/, e uno
dei proprietari assistenti cominciato a confezionare, uno per uno.
Balance 999 Homme Balance MS77 Femme rWxwi Abbiamo determinato
che un agnostico, la gente pelliccia bianca mi eccita ateo.
Albergo riassume pazzo in cima alla piramide di lusso PREZZO colore pazzo cosiddetto pazzo, pazzo per una giacca invernale e nutrire lo strumento in questa città piena di vapore..
Balance 574 Homme New Balance 3090 oXCIm Forse ho sentito
il nome sbagliato. Ho pensato che avrei potuto facilmente cercare online e ottenere le regole.

New Balance Minimus Zero Balance 1500 Homme mafxP Alla fine,
ha usato più volte Playtex nurser con CT in piedi e camminare, e mi uscì dalla stanza.
Si ritornati alla Medela, perché ho i materiali e tutto va bene.

Balance 577 Homme Balance MS77 Femme JYqBK Abbiamo in programma di espandere
la boutique altri articoli di lusso, ha detto said.Buxton una cosa boutique che li
distingue è stabilito, è che Bellman produrre i propri gioielli.
Noi abbiamo la nostra propria fabbrica con diamanti in Israele,
ha detto said.Because, Buxton ha detto che potevo passare il risparmio ai propri clienti.
New Balance 577 Balance 420 Homme vstUP Borsa carina e
bella Dooney Bourke Scottie cani di taglia piccola Est / Ovest è l'accessorio perfetto da indossare ogni
giorno. Questa piccola borsa del progettista dispone di una spaziosa tasca interna con zip, interno gancio chiave,
chiusura magnetica, utile tasca per cellulare,
cinturino in pelle mezzo, bella fodera scozzese, Dooney Bourke firma appeso etichetta con logo di cane e cane Scottie stampa allover.

08.28.14 at 3:31 AM
08.28.14 at 8:57 PM

Everything is very open with a very clear explanation of the challenges.
It was truly informative. Your site is extremely helpful.
Thanks for sharing!

Comment on this entry

(will not be published)
(optional -- Google will not follow)

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Pre-Order My Book!

small_final_covershot_dropshadow.jpg A wine book like no other. Photographs, essays, and wine recommendations. Learn more.

Follow Me On:

Twitter Facebook Pinterest Instagram Delectable Flipboard

Most Recent Entries

Earthquake Rattles Napa Harvest NIMBY Versus Vineyard in Malibu Vinography Images: Precious Droplets MORIC: The Apogee of Blaufränkisch 2014 Sonoma Wine Country Weekend: August 29-21, Healdsburg, CA The (Still) Dismal State of California Chardonnay What a Way to Go: Wine At the End of Your Life Vinography Images: Into the Tank 72 Pinot Noirs on a Sunny Afternoon: Tasting at IPNC 2014 The Great White South: An Introduction to Châteauneuf-du-Pape Blanc

Favorite Posts From the Archives

Masuizumi Junmai Daiginjo, Toyama Prefecture Wine.Com Gives Retailers (and Consumers) the Finger 1961 Hospices de Beaune Emile Chandesais, Burgundy Wine Over Time The Better Half of My Palate 1999 Királyudvar "Lapis" Tokaji Furmint, Hungary What's Allowed in Your Wine and Winemaking Why Community Tasting Notes Sites Will Fail Appreciating Wine in Context The Soul vs. The Market 1989 Fiorano Botte 48 Semillion,Italy

Archives by Month


Required Reading for Wine Lovers

The Oxford Companion to Wine by Jancis Robinson The Taste of Wine by Emile Peynaud Adventures on the Wine Route by Kermit Lynch Love By the Glass by Dorothy Gaiter & John Brecher Noble Rot by William Echikson The Science of Wine by Jamie Goode The Judgement of Paris by George Taber The Wine Bible by Karen MacNeil The Botanist and the Vintner by Christy Campbell The Emperor of Wine by Elin McCoy The World Atlas of Wine by Hugh Johnson The World's Greatest Wine Estates by Robert M. Parker, Jr.